Crawford Street Journal

Crawford Street Journal

Share this post

Crawford Street Journal
Crawford Street Journal
American League West Update
User's avatar
Discover more from Crawford Street Journal
Data-driven Astros analysis
Already have an account? Sign in

American League West Update

Game by Game

Marty Coleman
Aug 31, 2024
1

Share this post

Crawford Street Journal
Crawford Street Journal
American League West Update
Share

I thought for today I would update the AL West race and add a few odds and ends.

American League West Update

The Astros are very close to having a 90% chance of winning the West per fangraphs.

What that doesn’t mean is that Houston will win the West. It means they’re most likely to and those are very different things.

A four-game lead with 27 to go is good, but if anything I’d likely have lower odds, though I typically trust fangraphs, well except for their Wild Card odds (without further explanation or understanding how they got there).

The numbers below are mine.

To hit these Houston would have to go 15-12 which is certainly doable and reasonable.

If the Astros went 15-12, Seattle would need to go 19-8 to tie and the Mariners would have the tiebreaker unless the Astros can sweep Seattle in late September.

Each Astros win tightens the vice a little, each Mariner loss tightens it more.

A season long look at expected wins by my formula.

It’s been a slow and steady climb since early June, with a few smallish dips.

Crawford Street Journal is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

MLB Projected Standings

These are my numbers and are not predictive.

This is basically saying, “if they continue to play like they have they will end up like this”, because after all we have 135 or so data points.

LUCK

The Astros haven’t been very lucky on the season as a whole (my numbers) coming in 27th, just ahead of Kansas City.

This is based on wins and losses and run differential - the difference between what your record is and what it should be.

The larger the number is, the luckier the team has been. The smaller the number the unluckier a team has been.

Just on an observational basis this seems to fit the Astros with a bunch of tough, one run losses and weird happenings.

You can argue the White Sox aren’t unlucky, just horrid and I’d agree.

The White Sox likely broke this model this season, but I think it adds context when evaluating a team.

It shouldn’t be the only data used, but rather one more piece of data for an argument.

Why are the Rays considered the luckiest team in baseball by my calculations?

Well for starters they’ve been outscored by 63 runs, but are just one game under .500 after 133 games. They are 25-14 in one-run games which is unsustainable over the long term and 8-5 in extra innings.

In short, their season would look very different if they were 20-19 in one-run games and 7-6 in extras.

Take away those “luck” factors and you are looking at around a 60-73 team and a whole different feeling.

The Kikuchi Factor

The Astros are 5-0 when Yusei Kikuchi starts, winning thrice by one run.

Kikuchi has pitched 5.2 innings in 4 of his 5 Astros starts and 5.1 in the other.

Home Run Project

I have some preliminary findings on this, which is the exact opposite of what I thought going in.

I’ll share at a later date.

30-Day Bats and Arms

Thanks for reading.

Leave a comment

Share Crawford Street Journal

Share

1

Share this post

Crawford Street Journal
Crawford Street Journal
American League West Update
Share

Discussion about this post

User's avatar
The Future: Jacob Melton
The most anticipated prospect of the 2025 cycle
Nov 14, 2024 • 
Marty Coleman
3

Share this post

Crawford Street Journal
Crawford Street Journal
The Future: Jacob Melton
2
2025 Projection: Framber Valdez
With JV in Arizona, can the volatile Framber Valdez lead the staff?
Feb 25 • 
Marty Coleman
4

Share this post

Crawford Street Journal
Crawford Street Journal
2025 Projection: Framber Valdez
Final Roster Thoughts and AL West Prediction
The roster is complete, the stage is set and the season is here
Mar 26 • 
Marty Coleman
4

Share this post

Crawford Street Journal
Crawford Street Journal
Final Roster Thoughts and AL West Prediction
2

Ready for more?

© 2025 Marty Coleman
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share

Create your profile

User's avatar

Only paid subscribers can comment on this post

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in

Check your email

For your security, we need to re-authenticate you.

Click the link we sent to , or click here to sign in.