Excuse my tardiness; I’ve been out of town on a family matter and wanted to take some time to let the Astros’ front-office moves sink in.
While I was away, the Astros hired a new general manager and a new manager.
Whether they have a new direction remains the question, at least to me.
Second Choice?
Though perhaps not his first choice, Jim Crane hired Randy Flores to replace Dana Brown, and, less than two weeks later, Brad Ausmus was named to replace Joe Espada. The Astros have now filled two important vacancies, but the bigger questions surrounding the organization haven’t gone anywhere and, if possible, could loom even larger with that second hire.
Flores was reportedly among the early candidates interviewed for the position, but the search continued, creating the impression that Houston was looking elsewhere. Then came Milwaukee Brewers assistant general manager Matt Kleine, who certainly appeared to be Crane’s preferred choice.
After all, Crane practically paraded Kleine around like a brand-new toy at the Houston Sports Hall of Fame ceremony a few weeks ago. When an owner brings a potential general manager candidate to a high-profile public event like that, it’s hard not to believe he’s sending a message about the direction he wants to go.
Flores comes to Houston after 11 years in the St. Louis Cardinals organization, where he developed a reputation for his work in scouting and player acquisition. His background is intriguing, particularly for an Astros organization that hasn’t gotten nearly enough production from its barren farm system for several seasons.
The hiring also brings back memories of Crane reaching into the Cardinals organization to hire Jeff Luhnow in 2011. That decision worked out pretty well until it didn’t.
But Flores isn’t Luhnow, and the Astros aren’t the same organization they were 15 years ago.
The team is coming off the fourth consecutive season of fewer wins, despite winning their division, an accomplishment that speaks more to the mediocrity of the American League West than to any resurgence in Houston.
There are legitimate concerns about the roster, particularly the outfield, pitching depth and an aging core. Those problems aren’t going to disappear simply because someone new is occupying the general manager’s office.
Poor Optics
Then there’s the hiring of Ausmus.
The former Astros catcher certainly knows the organization, and his familiarity with Houston probably made him an attractive candidate. He also brings five years of managerial experience and three seasons as the Yankees’ bench coach.
But his previous managerial record of 386-422 isn’t exactly overwhelming.
And the fans, my son being one, generally HATE this hire.
Me? I would have gone in a different direction because optics matter, especially with the diminishing returns and general upheaval of recent seasons, which leave me feeling like perhaps Ausmus is a placeholder of the Dave Culley ilk.
Someone to take the beatings until morale or the roster improves, so to speak.
That’s not to suggest Ausmus can’t succeed in Houston. Managers learn, circumstances change, and the quality of the roster matters considerably more than most people want to acknowledge.
Still, it’s fair to wonder whether the Astros conducted a search for the best available manager or settled on somebody familiar.
Albert Pujols was “impressive” in his interview, but apparently not as impressive as Jeff Bagwell’s best friend.
It also raises questions of how much authority Flores actually has.
Again - optics.
Crane has said his new general manager will have control over baseball decisions, and Flores insists Ausmus was his choice. Perhaps that’s exactly how things unfolded.
On the other hand, with Jeff Bagwell remaining influential with Jim Crane, questions about the front office’s decision-making structure aren’t unreasonable, and this move fans those flames.
It will take time, but Flores needs to demonstrate that he can improve the roster without sacrificing the organization’s long-term future. He’s agreed to take the job and its limitations, whatever they may be. I wrote about a similar situation last month.
Ausmus needs to show that he can get more out of the players he’s given.
And Crane needs to give both men the opportunity to do their jobs.
Still Competitive?
As we sit here today, the Astros still have enough talent to compete in the AL West in 2027.
What they don’t have is the margin for error they enjoyed during their championship years. Not even close.
This was the easy part - Hiring a new general manager and manager, and it could be argued you botched that, particularly with the Ausmus hire.
Now comes the difficult part: Proving that anything has actually changed, because from the outside looking in, it looks pretty status quo at the moment.




